“X” is a feminist issue

Look, the fuss around whether race is a feminist issue (not just race, but race is a particular sore spot) boils down to this.

When people ask

“Why is X a feminist issue?”

what they’re really asking is

“Why should I care?”

I’m sorry. There’s no way to get around it.

The following is for my fellow white chicks. Bear with me, everyone.

If you are committed to feminist activism, what you are committed to is a framework of social justice built around gender. Right? You with me? What you care about is, specifically, women. But more broadly — stay with me here — what you care about is justice.

Right?

Gender is the organizing concept for you, most likely, because you are a woman. Ya? The way society organizes itself around gender makes you particularly aware of its effects, and that sparked your interest in this activism.

But that is just fucking ridiculous. Yeah, you’re a woman. But you’re also white. Why doesn’t that make you particularly aware of the way society structures itself around race? I’ll bet you don’t think men are ungendered — come on. So why aren’t you also dripping with race? Why isn’t race your organizing concept?

I’ll let you think for a while on that.*

Really: Why isn’t it worth your time to consider race in the same frame of mind you consider gender? Do you think that because you are white, it doesn’t affect you? I beg to differ! And I’ll bet you think men are negatively affected by society’s gendered structure too.

Do you think that there is nothing to learn, no benefit gain, for you or anyone else, from entering a framework other people have built, which doesn’t center around your world? Do you think it will have no relevance to your own life? Do you think it will have no relevance to your own activism?

Why is it that you have to be cajoled into showing some fucking respect for anything that doesn’t revolve around you and your experience?

You care about justice — right? Isn’t that, ultimately, what it comes down to? If you agree, then why are you putting up such a fight? What are you fighting for?

This is what I think.

Feminism is a framework dedicated to social justice, built around examining… let’s leave that blank for a moment.

Feminism is a framework dedicated to social justice.

Feminism cares about every person, no matter their (blank).

Feminism says, you deserve good, because you are a human being.

Feminism says, (blank) should not affect whether or not you receive that good, and we will fight to ensure that.

Feminism wants every person to be treated with respect, to be allowed dignity, autonomy, and self-actuation, on the basis of their shared humanity — and nothing else.

Now, to fill in that blank: feminism is a framework dedicated to social justice, built around examining gender.

But gender is not the only social construction thrust upon your unsuspecting self.

If it is the only one you see — or the one you see most clearly –there may just be a reason for this.

Has to do with social construction n stuff.

That’s all for now, folks.

—————————————————————————————

* BONUS. It killed the flow, but it’s important.

Consider also these: are you straight? younger in age? able-bodied? middle class or higher? If so: why haven’t you devoted your energies to activism built around age? sexuality? ability? Anything? — Beuller?

Is it because you don’t think those things really apply to you? But come on — you don’t think men are ungendered. So why aren’t you also dripping with these things? Why aren’t they your organizing concept?…

5 responses

octogalore

| Sunday, March 8, 2009 | 6:58 pm

Amandaw — interesting take.I’m glad you said this isn’t a response to my piece, because I was not challenging: (a) “Why isn’t it worth your time to consider race in the same frame of mind you consider gender?”(b)  ”Do you think that there is nothing to learn, no benefit gain, for you or anyone else, from entering a framework other people have built, which doesn’t center around your world?” (b) “Why is it that you have to be cajoled into showing some fucking respect for anything that doesn’t revolve around you and your experience?”Cuz the anwswers to these are: (a) it is worh our time; (b) there is much to learn; and (c) nobody should have to be cajoled.But: none of that makes a discussion pf MOC (or men period) that doesn’t only gives lip service (and barely that) to any relevance to WOC (or women period) a feminist issue.And the reason for the annoying harping on this is that subordinating ourselves, especially our most underserved members in something that is supposed to be a feminist issue is problematic.  There are many forums where it is the responsibility of anyone involved in any justice movement to learn about other justice issues that do not directly involve women of any color or description.  Hopefully, none of this is meant to refute that.

octogalores last blog post..Arms

amandaw

| Sunday, March 8, 2009 | 7:07 pm

O ya, it just set me thinking. My thought process could hardly be called linear :) I was thinking because it was bothering me, why don’t the examples she gave feel like “feminist”? And that’s when I thought, “what is it this argument is getting at? what is all the way at the bottom of this, and what else is there along the way?” and this is what came out of that journey.

I didn’t link to your post in this one very deliberately, even though it sparked my train of thought, because it was not on the same subject line at all. You threaded together a beautiful point about the invisibility of women of color in these discussions. Like I said — picking up on some of the things that are sitting there while you’re trying to dig all the way to the bottom of this.

octogalore

| Sunday, March 8, 2009 | 8:45 pm

Thanks! And sorry my editing is so sucky above.

Can you clarify “why don’t the examples she gave feel like “feminist”?”

octogalores last blog post..Arms

amandaw

| Sunday, March 8, 2009 | 8:55 pm

Para beginning with “Well, I had to admit, something bugged me …” (this post)

and I don’t know if it’s my body winding down at the end of the day or just me being an idiot but I may have crossed paths, sorta, in which post was which and which post I was thinking of (the above, but I can’t find it in the Feministe post I commented on which either means I’ve lost all mental faculty or I assumed one post linked was another.)

Opopanox, Home of the Arrogant Worm

| Monday, March 9, 2009 | 9:39 pm

[...] Link located Here [...]

Leave a comment

You can use these tags : <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>